I Love When Joe Shmoe Gives Parenting Advice

Ergo carrier

Our first foray into the baby backpack. Looks comfy to me!

I was lucky during my pregnancy in that, for the most part, people didn’t view my large belly as an open invitation to give me their birth horror stories or outdated advice. I’ve heard stories about rude comments from strangers, but I never experienced that, although I did notice people not-so-subtly gaping at my girth.

Since my daughter arrived, I’ve gotten unsolicited advice a couple of times from strangers. Once, when leaving a restaurant, I was loading a crying, hungry baby into her infant car seat. I was trying to focus on getting her properly restrained under pressure when a woman stopped on her way out the door. “She has gas,” she declared expertly before giving me step-by-step instructions on what I needed to do and exactly how I needed to do it to relieve the “gas.” I was so flabbergasted and preoccupied that I couldn’t even respond to the know-it-all that actually, it had been a few hours since she’d last eaten and she was getting hungry.

Cut to yesterday. I desperately wanted a cup of coffee and had no creamer on hand. So I packed Avery up in her Ergo baby carrier and headed to our corner store. Now, I have worn Avery on my chest numerous times in the carrier, but had only carried her once before on my back. After several minutes of acrobatics that could get me a spot in a circus sideshow, I got her adjusted, straps tightened. I checked her out in the mirror to make sure she looked comfortable and headed out the door.

Coffee in hand, I went to pay at the store. The lady behind the counter tells me that the baby doesn’t look “comfortable.” I’m thinking, oh, crap, I must not have gotten her in it very good! Until she says, “The strap is in her face, and her legs look too wide.” I knew her legs were totally fine (especially after looking at this particular photo!), but on our way to the pharmacy down the street, I checked our reflection in several storefronts to be sure—all was fine, baby was happy. Then, checking out at the pharmacy, the cashier says, “Are you sure she’s comfortable?”

One random person commenting? Could be a fluke. Two people questioning me in one day? I figured something must be wrong that I couldn’t see, so I walked home quick-fast-in-a-hurry and did a mirror check. All was fine; baby was still happy as a clam. But I was bummed out, feeling like I’d been a bad parent.

I of course want to do what’s best for my baby, which is why I went to great lengths to make sure she was comfortable (even holding up a hand mirror at the pharmacy to check on her). Had she been fussing or squirming, I wouldn’t have played the I’m-right/mom-martyr game; I would have adjusted her so she’d be comfortable.

So, who knows. Maybe Avery had on her “I’m about to poop” face; maybe these women had never seen a baby carrier before; maybe they just wanted to be nosy. Whatever the reason for the two-banger Tuesday, I’m going to try not to let it make me super paranoid the next time out. Or let it make me feel like my mommy skills are lacking because, after all, everyone’s parenting style is different and aren’t we all just doing the best we can?

How do you moms handle unsolicited baby advice or comments? What’s the worst unsolicited advice you’ve ever gotten? —Erin


  1. Stacie says

    Most of my unsolicited advice comes from my MIL, who is of the school “Children Should be Seen and not Heard”. So she’s always telling us that we should get our kids tested for ADHD, Autism, etc, because they make too much noise and are too active. I just smile and nod. From strangers though (depending on who they are), they get anything from a small smile to a huge grin and a “Oh, thank you so much for the unsolicited advice! It’s very helpful.”(Yes, exact words)
    Don’t let it get you down, there is ALWAYS going to be someone that has to tell you how it’s “supposed” to be done. You know your baby, they don’t.

  2. Desiree says

    So glad you didn’t get the birthing horror stories. I went to a friend’s birthday party (30 years old) and got some of the worst. I am due at the end of April and wondered what would possess someone to share those types of stories with a woman who was a bout to give birth. Seriously?!

    As for unsolicited stuffs, I had a complete stranger come up to me and touch my belly a few months ago asking when I was due. I wish I could bold the “complete stranger” part because I had no clue who the lady was. I looked her in the eye and asked her if she would like me to grab or touch her breasts because what she was doing to my belly was just as inappropriate. She apologized profusely and went about her shopping at the store.

  3. Todd says

    My canned response in these situations was, “Weird, that’s not what she told me.” Please feel free to use it. Another favorite was, “Oh, thank you, Dr. Spock!” as I go about my business.

    Stories from others are just par for the course. The unsolicited advice though, that drove my wife and I nuts.

    Baby looks perfectly happy back there.

  4. Nichol says

    Once I was out with my daughter a little too close to naptime and she started to cry. As I was carrying her out of the store (sans purchases, mind you) a woman BLOCKED my path to berate me for not caring for her properly. Luckily, MY mom was along and took care of it, but I wanted to cry. Later, I just chalked it up to that lady’s lack of boundaries. BTW, my children both preferred being in their carriers to any type of stroller, cart, etc.

  5. A-man-Duh says

    Best unsolicited “advice” while I was pregnant: on December 24, the date I was due with my daughter I was doing a little last-minute shopping and a woman asked when I was due, “Today.” I told her. She informed me that I was carrying so high and since the baby hadn’t “dropped” yet I wouldn’t be delivering for weeks! Yeah. Sure. (I went into labor 2 days later and delivered on December 28.)


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *